Scribbling on the Shoulders of Giants

And then Indiana Jones
fights Lord Voledmort…

This week’s literary bombshell was Amazon’s news that they would publish fan-fiction in such a way that the original copyright holders of characters and settings would be compensated. Kindle Words, apparently, divvies up the royalties between the new and old authors–but the new writers have to give up their own copyrights in a delicious bit of irony.

Fair use and copyright expiration, as I tell my library research students, exist because we need to be able to build on what’s come before to create something new. Anything published before 1923 is already fair game, so we’ve seen books like Wide Sargasso Sea and Silver: Return to Treasure Island. There have been a plethora of Pride and Prejudice riffs, some of which would  have Jane Austen spinning in her grave. (Or, in other versions, rising from her grave to kill upstart writers.)

I love to see ideas and characters get a second life, but fan fiction? Some (a lot) of it is dreadful. Some (a shocking amount) is pornographic because people have sick minds. According to paidContent’s article, there will be some limits on what will be published:

Kindle Worlds won’t publish all of the works submitted to it; it will only accept some (though the company says it aims to accept as many as possible, as long as they adhere to content guidelines).

The content guidelines rule out slash fiction and other fantasies, so there’s that at least.

I’ve seen two kinds of reactions so far. There are writers who are miffed that the fanfic writers will lose their copyright, which is prevented be a lot of author guild rules. The other reaction is horror that fan fiction will gain some legitimacy through Kindle Words. The reaction I haven’t see is no one is pointing out that neither Kindle Words nor the potential authors are asking permission of the living copyright holders. In this instance, I think copyright is protecting characters and ideas and settings from being cheapened by writers who can’t or won’t stay true to them, or who don’t have the chops or wit to make something new and shiny out of them. To me, that’s more important than the money that would be changing hands.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s